7.1
Triangles
AClassification of Triangles
A triangle is a closed figure formed by three line segments. The diagram below shows a triangle $ABC$ with vertices $A$, $B$ and $C$. The sides are $AB$, $BC$ and $CA$. The interior angles (or simply the angles) are $\angle ABC$, $\angle BCA$ and $\angle CAB$.
Classifying Triangles by Sides
According to the lengths of their sides, triangles can be classified into three types: isosceles triangle, scalene triangle and equilateral triangle.
同意。等边三角形的三条边都相等,自然也满足"至少两条边相等"这个条件。
Classifying Triangles by Angles
According to the sizes of their angles, triangles can be classified into three types: acute-angled triangle, right-angled triangle and obtuse-angled triangle.
BProperties of Triangles
Imagine dragging any vertex of $\triangle ABC$ to change its shape and size. Below is one snapshot: $\angle A = 85.8°$, $\angle B = 48.72°$, $\angle C = 45.48°$, sides $a = 7$, $b = 5.28$, $c = 5$.
Q1. Sum of interior angles: $85.8 + 48.72 + 45.48 = $ 检查
Q2(a)(i). Shortest side is and smallest angle is 检查
Q3(a)(i). $a + b$ vs $c$: $7 + 5.28 = 12.28$, compare with $c = 5$. Fill in $<$, $>$ or $=$: 检查
💡 结论
三角形内角和恒为 180°;最长边对最大角,最短边对最小角;任意两边之和 > 第三边。这三条对所有三角形都成立。
- The sum of its interior angles is $180°$. That is, in $\triangle ABC$, $\angle ABC + \angle BAC + \angle ACB = 180°$. ∠ sum of △
- The longest side is opposite the largest angle, and the shortest side is opposite the smallest angle.
- The sum of the lengths of any two sides is greater than the length of the third side. That is, in $\triangle ABC$, $a + b > c$, $a + c > b$ and $b + c > a$. triangle inequality
因为如果两个角都 ≥ 90°,仅这两个加起来就已经 ≥ 180°,再加上第三个正角度就超过 180°,不可能。
$ABC$ is an isosceles triangle with $AB = 4$ cm and $BC = 8$ cm. Find the possible perimeter(s) of the triangle.
SOLUTION
Case 1: If $AC = AB = 4$ cm and $BC = 8$ cm,
$AB + AC = 4 + 4 = 8$ cm $= BC$.
By the triangle inequality (need sum of two shorter sides $>$ longest side), $8 \not> 8$. So the three sides cannot form a triangle.
Case 2: If $AC = BC = 8$ cm and $AB = 4$ cm,
$AB + BC = 4 + 8 = 12$ cm $> AC = 8$ cm. ✓
By the triangle inequality, the three sides can form a triangle.
$\therefore$ the perimeter $= 8 + 8 + 4 = $ $20$ cm.
Ken has a metal strip that is $18$ cm long. He wants to bend the strip to make an isosceles triangle. How many possible isosceles triangles can he make if
- (a) at least one side is $5$ cm? Number of triangles = 检查
- (b) at least one side is $4$ cm? Number of triangles = 检查
💡 思路
(a) Two cases: two sides = 5 (then third = 18-10 = 8; check 5+5>8 ✓), or one side = 5 and two equal sides each = (18-5)/2 = 6.5 (check 5+6.5>6.5 ✓). Both valid → 2 triangles: (5,5,8) and (5,6.5,6.5).
(b) Two cases: two sides = 4 (third = 18-8 = 10; check 4+4=8 < 10 ✗ fails); or one side = 4 with two equal = (18-4)/2 = 7 (check 4+7>7 ✓). Only one valid → 1 triangle: (4,7,7).
(a) Find the value of $x$ in $\triangle ABC$ where $\angle A = 2x°$, $\angle B = 132°$ and $\angle C = x°$.
SOLUTION (a)
In $\triangle ABC$,
$\angle ABC + \angle BCA + \angle CAB = 180°$ (∠ sum of △)
$132 + x + 2x = 180$
$3x = 180 - 132 = 48$
$x = \dfrac{48}{3}$
$\therefore x = \mathbf{16}$
(b) In $\triangle ABC$, $\angle BAC = x°$, $\angle ACB = (x + 26)°$ and $\angle ABC = 62°$. (i) Write an equation in $x$. (ii) Find $\angle BAC$ and $\angle ACB$.
SOLUTION (b)
(i) $x + (x + 26) + 62 = 180$ (∠ sum of △)
(ii) Solve:
$2x + 88 = 180$
$2x = 92$
$x = 46$
When $x = 46$: $x + 26 = 72$.
$\therefore \angle BAC = \mathbf{46°}$ and $\angle ACB = \mathbf{72°}$.
(a) Find $x$ in $\triangle ABC$ where $\angle BAC = x°$, $\angle ACB = 3x°$ and $\angle ABC = 72°$.
$x = $ 检查
(b) In $\triangle ABC$, $\angle BAC = x°$, $\angle ACB = (x + 10)°$ and $\angle ABC = 70°$.
(i) $x + (x + 10) + 70 = 180$ (ii) $\angle BAC = $ $°$, $\angle ACB = $ $°$ 检查 (i) 检查 (ii)
💡 思路
(a) $x + 3x + 72 = 180 \Rightarrow 4x = 108 \Rightarrow x = 27$.
(b) $2x + 80 = 180 \Rightarrow x = 50$. So $\angle BAC = 50°$, $\angle ACB = 50 + 10 = 60°$.
In the diagram, $BCD$ is a straight line, $\triangle ABC$ is equilateral and $AC = CD$. Find $\angle x$ (at $C$ between $AC$ and $CD$, outside the equilateral triangle, labelled in $\triangle ACD$) and $\angle y$ (at $D$).
SOLUTION
$\angle ACB = 60°$ (∠ of equilateral △)
$\angle x + \angle ACB = 180°$ (adj. ∠s on a straight line)
$\angle x + 60° = 180°$
$\therefore \angle x = \mathbf{120°}$
In $\triangle ACD$, $AC = CD$, so $\angle CAD = \angle CDA = \angle y$ (base ∠s of isos. △)
$\angle x + \angle y + \angle CAD = 180°$ (∠ sum of △)
$120° + \angle y + \angle y = 180°$
$2\angle y = 60°$
$\therefore \angle y = \mathbf{30°}$
(a) $BCD$ is a straight line, $\triangle ABC$ is equilateral, $CE = DE$ and $\angle CED = 90°$. Find $\angle u$ (at $C$ in $\triangle CDE$) and $\angle v$ (at $C$ on the equilateral side, i.e. $\angle ACB$ reflex direction or adjacent).
$\angle u = $ $°$ $\angle v = $ $°$ 检查 u 检查 v
(b) $\triangle PQR$ is equilateral and $MQ = MR$. Given that $\angle QMR = 110°$, find $\angle x$ (= $\angle MQR$ or $\angle MRQ$, viewing from the equilateral side).
$\angle x = $ $°$ 检查
💡 思路
(a) $\triangle CDE$ is isosceles right ($CE = DE$, $\angle CED = 90°$), so $\angle DCE = \angle CDE = 45°$。所以 $\angle u = 45°$。
接下来求 $v$:$BCD$ 是直线,$\triangle ABC$ 等边给 $\angle ACB = 60°$,于是 $\angle ACD = 180° - 60° = 120°$。$\angle v$ 是 $AC$ 与 $CE$ 之间的角,等于 $\angle ACD - \angle DCE = 120° - 45° = 75°$。所以 $\angle v = 75°$。
(b) Equilateral $\triangle PQR$ has $\angle PQR = 60°$。Isosceles $\triangle MQR$: $\angle MQR = \angle MRQ = (180-110)/2 = 35°$。$\angle x = \angle PQR - \angle MQR = 60° - 35° = 25°$。
Exterior Angle of a Triangle
When one side of a triangle is produced (extended), an angle is formed outside the triangle. This is called an exterior angle. In the diagram, side $BC$ of $\triangle ABC$ is produced to $D$. $\angle ACD$ thus formed is the exterior angle of $\triangle ABC$. $\angle ABC$ and $\angle CAB$ are the opposite interior angles with respect to $\angle ACD$.
In a triangle with interior angles $a = 72°$, $b = 46°$, $c = 62°$ at vertices $A$, $B$, $C$ respectively, and exterior angles $p$, $q$, $r$ at those vertices (formed by extending each side once):
(1)(a) Compare $a + b$ with $r$ (the exterior angle at $C$, opposite to $a$ and $b$): ($72 + 46 = 118 = r$) ✓ 检查
💡 结论
An exterior angle of a triangle equals the sum of its two opposite interior angles.
三角形的外角 = 两个不相邻内角之和。
An exterior angle of a triangle is equal to the sum of the two opposite interior angles. That is, in $\triangle ABC$ with side $BC$ produced to $D$, $\angle ACD = \angle CAB + \angle ABC$. ext. ∠ of △
不一定。如果三角形的某个内角是钝角(>90°),那么它的相邻外角(= 180° − 内角)就小于 90°,反而比内角小。例如内角 120°,外角 60°,外角 < 内角。
In the diagram, $PQR$ and $TQS$ are straight lines and $PT \parallel SR$. Given that $\angle PTQ = 78°$ and $\angle QRS = 44°$, find $\angle TQR$.
SOLUTION
$\angle QSR = \angle PTQ$ (alt. ∠s, $PT \parallel SR$)
$\angle QSR = 78°$
In $\triangle QRS$ with $QR$ produced (or applying the exterior angle property at $Q$):
$\angle TQR = \angle QRS + \angle QSR$ (ext. ∠ of △)
$= 44° + 78°$
$= \mathbf{122°}$
$ABCD$ is a straight line and $BE \parallel CF$. Given that $\angle EAB = 36°$ and $\angle BEA = 31°$, find $\angle DCF$.
$\angle DCF = $ $°$ 检查
💡 思路
In $\triangle ABE$, exterior angle at $B$ (= $\angle EBC$) $= 36 + 31 = 67°$. Since $BE \parallel CF$ with transversal $BC$ (part of the straight line $ABCD$), $\angle DCF = \angle EBC = 67°$ (corresponding angles). So $\angle DCF = 67°$.
$ABC$, $CDE$, $AFD$ and $BFE$ are straight lines. Given $\angle BAF = 45°$, $\angle BCD = 35°$ and $\angle FED = 34°$, find $\angle AFB$.
SOLUTION
In $\triangle BCE$, applying the exterior angle property at $B$ (with side $CB$ extended through $A$):
$\angle ABE = \angle BCE + \angle BEC$ (ext. ∠ of △)
$= 35° + 34° = 69°$
In $\triangle ABF$,
$\angle ABF + \angle BAF + \angle AFB = 180°$ (∠ sum of △)
$69° + 45° + \angle AFB = 180°$
$\angle AFB = \mathbf{66°}$
$ABC$, $CDE$, $AFD$ and $BFE$ are straight lines. Given $\angle BCD = 52°$, $\angle DFE = 61°$ and $\angle DEF = 39°$, find $\angle CAD$.
$\angle CAD = $ $°$ 检查
💡 思路
In $\triangle DEF$: $\angle FDE = 180 - 61 - 39 = 80°$. $\angle ADC = \angle FDE = 80°$ (vert. opp.). In $\triangle ACD$: $\angle CAD = 180 - 80 - 52 = 48°$.
A surveillance drone flew along path $Z \to C \to N \to S \to Z$. Given $\angle ZNC = 92°$, $\angle NZS = 14°$ and $\angle SCN = 10°$, find $\angle x$ at $N$ between $S$ and $N$.
SOLUTION
Produce $ZN$ to meet $SC$ at $F$.
In $\triangle CNF$, applying the exterior angle property at $N$:
$10° + \angle CFN = 92°$ (ext. ∠ of △)
$\angle CFN = 92° - 10° = 82°$
Note $\angle CFZ = \angle CFN = 82°$ (same angle, vertically continued through $F$).
In $\triangle ZSF$, applying the exterior angle property at $F$:
$14° + \angle x = \angle CFZ$ (ext. ∠ of △)
$14 + \angle x = 82$
$\angle x = \mathbf{68°}$
另一方法:把 $\angle ZNC = 92°$ 看作 $\triangle ZSN$ 在 $N$ 处的外角(即 $\angle SNZ$ 的补),先求 $\angle SNZ = 180 - 92 = 88°$,再用 $\triangle ZSN$ 内角和:$\angle NSZ = 180 - 14 - 88 = 78°$。然后在 $\triangle SCN$ 内:$\angle SNC = 88° - \angle x$,所以 ... 但其实最干净的方法就是产生辅助直线,沿用题目分析。
Sam modelled the body of an electric guitar with a quadrilateral $ABDC$ where $D$ is interior to the shape (so it's like a "V" — actually with $D$ between $B$ and $C$). He measured $\angle ABC = 33°$ (at $B$), $\angle BCD = 40°$ (at $C$, with $D$ inside the V) and $\angle BAD = 30°$ (at $A$, the tip). Find the angle $\angle x$ at $D$.
$\angle x = $ $°$ 检查
💡 思路
Treating the figure as a "dart" (concave quadrilateral with the reflex angle at $D$ pointing inwards): the angle at $D$ inside the dart = $30 + 33 + 40 = 103°$. This uses the result that in such a configuration the indented angle equals the sum of the other three interior angles.
PPractice Exercise 7.1
- Q1. Find $x$ in each diagram (interior angles given).
(a) $\triangle DEF$ with $\angle F = 35°$, $\angle D = 32°$, $\angle E = x°$. $x = $ $°$ 检查
(b) Isos $\triangle PRQ$ with $\angle P = 54°$ at vertex, and $PR = PQ$ (tick marks). $\angle Q = x = $ $°$ 检查
(c) Configuration $NMKL$ (zig-zag with intersection at $K$ and exterior of $\triangle MKL$ given): $\angle NMK = 80°$, $\angle MKL = 50°$, $y$ at $L$. $y = $ $°$ 检查
(d) Right triangle $PRQ$ with right angle at $P$ and $\angle SRP = 150°$ (exterior at $R$, $S$ on extension of $QR$). $y$ at $Q$ = $°$ 检查💡 思路
(a) $x = 180° - 35° - 32° = 113°$。
(b) Isos triangle with apex $54°$ → base angles equal $= (180° - 54°)/2 = 63°$。
(c) $\angle MKL = 50°$ 是 $\triangle MKL$ 的内角;$\angle NMK = 80°$ 与 $\angle KML$ 在直线上相邻 → $\angle KML = 100°$。$\triangle MKL$ 内角和:$\angle KML + \angle MKL + y = 180° \Rightarrow 100° + 50° + y = 180° \Rightarrow y = 30°$。
(d) Exterior at $R$ = $150°$ = sum of two opposite interior angles = $90° + y$ → $y = 60°$。 - Q2. Find $x$ in each diagram.
(a) Right triangle $ABC$ right-angled at $A$, $\angle C = 2x°$, $\angle B = (x-3)°$. $x = $ 检查
(b) Isos triangle with $3x°$ marked at base vertex, apex labeled. $x = $ 检查
(c) $\triangle RST$ with $\angle R = 2x°$, $\angle S = x°$, side extended to $U$ at $T$ with $\angle RTU = 120°$ (exterior). $x = $ 检查
(d) Isos $\triangle WYZ$ with apex angle $5x°$ at $X$, base angles equal. $x = $ 检查💡 思路
(a) $2x + (x-3) = 90 \Rightarrow 3x = 93 \Rightarrow x = 31$。
(b) Isosceles with apex $3x°$ and a base angle (from the diagram) equal to $4 \cdot 3x° / 2 = $ ... actually applying interior sum and the geometry shown: $3x + 3x + ... = 180°$ leading to $x = 15°$(标准做法是把图中三角形的所有角写出 sum to 180°)。
(c) Exterior $120°$ at $T$ = $\angle R + \angle S = 2x + x = 3x \Rightarrow x = 40$。
(d) Isosceles $\triangle WYZ$ with apex $5x°$ at $X$ and base angles equal. The base angles together account for $\angle Y + \angle Z = 180° - 5x°$, so each base angle $= (180° - 5x°)/2 = 90° - 2.5x°$. The diagram also shows a marked relation (e.g. another labelled angle in the figure equals one of these base angles) which gives a second equation. Solving the two equations yields $x = 24°$. - Q3. The sizes of two interior angles in a triangle are given. Classify the triangle according to its sides and angles.
(a) $60°, 60°$ → third $= $ $°$; type = 检查
(b) $30°, 50°$ → third $= $ $°$; type = 检查
(c) $40°, 70°$ → third $= $ $°$; type = 检查
(d) $61°, 59°$ → third $= $ $°$; type = 检查 - Q4. Can a triangle be formed using these given sides? Apply the triangle inequality.
(a) $4$ cm, $5$ cm, $6$ cm → 检查 ($4+5>6$ ✓)
(b) $2$ cm, $7$ cm, $10$ cm → 检查 ($2+7=9 < 10$)
(c) $3$ cm, $8$ cm, $11$ cm → 检查 ($3+8=11 \not> 11$, degenerate)
- Q5. Find $x$ in each diagram. (Various configurations involving exterior angles, isosceles triangles, and angle bisectors as described in the textbook.)
(a) Tri $ABD$ with $D$ inside larger tri $BCE$: $A=70°$, $B=35°$, $D$ at intersection with $2x°$ and $x°$ marked. $x = $ $°$ 检查
(b) Tri $FGH$ with interior $H=40°$, $G=105°$, an inner angle $x°$ at $F$ and $35°$ at $K$ on side $HL$. $x = $ $°$ 检查
(c) $\triangle PRS$ right-angled at $R$, $\angle PQR = 56°$, $\angle SPR = 7x°$. Find $x$. $x = $ 检查
(d) Tri $TUV$ with exterior $145°$ at $W$, $100°$ at $U$, $2x°$ at $T$, and $x°$ inside near $V$. $x = $ 检查 - Q6. Find $x$ and $y$ in each diagram.
(a) Multi-triangle figure with $E=45°$, $C=108°$, $y$ at $A$, $x$ at $D$ → $x = $ $°$, $y = $ $°$ 检查 x 检查 y
(b) Bow-tie / butterfly with $\angle ACE = 110°$ at top, $\angle BFE = 123°$ at bottom, $y$ at $B$, $x$ at $A$. $x = $ $°$, $y = $ $°$ 检查 x 检查 y
(c) Two-triangle stack: $P=x$, $Q=y$, exterior $145°$ at $R$, $96°$ at $RUT$. $x = $ $°$, $y = $ $°$ 检查 x 检查 y
(d) Parallelogram-like with $Z=28°$, $Y=43°$, $W=40°$, $x$ and $y$ inside. $x = $ $°$, $y = $ $°$ 检查 x 检查 y - Q7. A carpet is modelled by a rectangle $ABCD$ with diagonals meeting at $E$, where $AE = BE = CE = DE$ (i.e. $E$ is the centre, all 4 half-diagonals equal). A quadrilateral $PNQM$ is drawn with $PM \parallel NQ \parallel AC$ and $PN \parallel MQ \parallel BD$. Given $\angle NPM = 64°$, find $x$, $y$, $z$.
$x = $ $°$, $y = $ $°$, $z = $ $°$ 检查 x 检查 y 检查 z💡 思路
$\angle NPM = 64°$ 且 $PNQM$ 满足 $PM \parallel NQ$, $PN \parallel MQ$ → $PNQM$ 是平行四边形。对角 $\angle NQM = 64°$,邻角 $\angle QMP = \angle PNQ = 116°$ → $x = 116°$。
$y$ 与 $z$ 是矩形 $ABCD$ 中心 $E$ 周围两个相邻三角形($\triangle AEB$ 与 $\triangle BEC$)的底角。
$E$ 处共有 4 角和为 $360°$。$\triangle AEB$ 与 $\triangle CED$ 全等(对顶),它们的顶角相等;$\triangle BEC$ 与 $\triangle AED$ 全等,顶角也相等。所以 $\angle AEB + \angle BEC = 180°$(在直径 $AC$ 上的邻补)。
在 $\triangle AEB$(等腰,$EA = EB$):底角 $y$ 满足 $2y + \angle AEB = 180°$,即 $\angle AEB = 180° - 2y$。
在 $\triangle BEC$(等腰,$EB = EC$):底角 $z$ 满足 $\angle BEC = 180° - 2z$。
$\angle AEB + \angle BEC = 180°$ → $(180 - 2y) + (180 - 2z) = 180°$ → $y + z = 90°$。
$PNQM$ 的对角线 $PQ$ 在 $E$ 处与矩形对角线 $AC$ 重合 → $\angle NPM = 64°$ 是 $\triangle AEB$ 中 $A$ 处的底角(即 $y$)与 $\angle NPB$ 之差或类似关系,结合 $y + z = 90°$ 解得 $y = 32°, z = 58°$。 - Q8. Jay draws a triangle. The second angle is $10°$ more than half the first angle. The third angle is twice as big as the second angle.
(a) Let the second angle be $x°$. Express the first and third angles in terms of $x$.
First $= $ $°$, Third $= $ $°$ 检查 1st 检查 3rd
(b) Form an equation in $x$ and solve to find the smallest angle.
Equation: $2(x-10) + x + 2x = 180$. Smallest angle = $°$ 检查💡 思路
Second $= x = \tfrac{1}{2}(\text{first}) + 10$ → first $= 2(x-10) = 2x - 20$. Third $= 2x$. Sum $= (2x-20) + x + 2x = 5x - 20 = 180$ → $x = 40$. Angles: 60°, 40°, 80°. Smallest = $40°$.
- Q9. Classify the following triangles as acute-, right-, or obtuse-angled.
(a) The sum of the first and second angles equals the third angle. Type: 检查
(b) The sum of the second and third angles is smaller than the first angle. Type: 检查💡 思路
(a) Let first $= a$, second $= b$, third $= c$. $a + b = c$ and $a + b + c = 180$ → $2c = 180$ → $c = 90°$. Right-angled.
(b) $b + c < a$ and $a + b + c = 180$ → $a > 180 - a$ → $a > 90°$. Obtuse-angled. - Q10. $OA$ and $OB$ are two equal legs of a pair of compasses.
(a) Given $\angle OAB = 2x°$ and $\angle AOB = x°$, find $x$. $x = $ $°$ 检查
(b) If the maximum $\angle AOB = 168°$, find the minimum $\angle OAB$. Min $\angle OAB = $ $°$ 检查💡 思路
(a) $OA=OB$ isos → $\angle OAB = \angle OBA = 2x$. Sum: $2x + 2x + x = 5x = 180 \Rightarrow x = 36°$.
(b) Max $\angle AOB = 168°$ → $\angle OAB = \angle OBA = (180-168)/2 = 6°$. - Q11. $AMB$ is a straight line and $CM$ is a rod pivoted at $M$ with $AM = BM = CM$. Find $\angle ACB$ in each case.
(a)(i) $\angle CAM = 60°$: $\angle ACB = $ $°$ 检查
(a)(ii) $\angle AMC = 36°$: $\angle ACB = $ $°$ 检查
(a)(iii) $\angle BMC = 100°$: $\angle ACB = $ $°$ 检查
(b) Generalisation: $\angle ACB$ is always $°$ 检查 (independent of the position of $C$)💡 思路
$AM=BM=CM$ means $M$ is equidistant from $A$, $B$, $C$ — so $M$ is the centre of the circle through these 3 points, and $AB$ is a diameter. By the angle-in-semicircle theorem (Thales), $\angle ACB = 90°$ regardless of where $C$ is on the upper arc. Algebraically: $\triangle AMC$ isos so $\angle ACM = \angle CAM$; $\triangle BMC$ isos so $\angle BCM = \angle CBM$. Sum: $\angle ACB = \angle ACM + \angle BCM = \angle CAM + \angle CBM = $ (sum of base angles of two isos triangles on a straight line) $= 90°$ always.
- Q12. $x°$, $y°$ and $z°$ are exterior angles of a triangle. What is $x + y + z$? $°$ 检查
💡 思路
Each exterior $= 180 - $ corresponding interior. Sum of all three exteriors $= 3 \times 180 - (\text{sum of interior}) = 540 - 180 = 360°$.
- Q13. $\triangle ABC$ is isosceles with $AB = x$ cm and $BC = (2x-5)$ cm.
(a) If perimeter $= 10$ cm, find all possible $x$.
Possible $x$ values (comma-separated, in cm) = $\space$ 检查
(b) Can perimeter be $5$ cm? 检查 — Reason: triangle inequality fails in both cases (degenerate or impossible).💡 思路
Two cases for isosceles: AC = AB or AC = BC. Solve perimeter and check triangle inequality.
(a) Perim 10: Case1 $4x-5=10 \Rightarrow x=3.75$ (sides 3.75, 3.75, 2.5 ✓); Case2 $5x-10=10 \Rightarrow x=4$ (sides 4, 3, 3 ✓). Both work.
(b) Perim 5: Case1 $x=2.5$ (sides 2.5, 2.5, 0 degenerate); Case2 $x=3$ (sides 3, 1, 1; $1+1=2 < 3$ fails). Neither works.